Skip to content

Florida Real Estate Litigation Attorneys · Practice Area

Florida HOA Disputes Attorney

Florida HOA dispute representation for homeowners facing improper fines, selective enforcement, special assessments, architectural denials, and threatened HOA foreclosure.

Florida HOA Dispute Attorney | Homeowners Association Litigation Lawyer

At Bernhardt Riley, Attorneys at Law, PLLC, in Palm Harbor, we understand that homeowners association disputes can be more than just legal challenges — they’re personal. When your HOA is fining you, threatening foreclosure, or selectively enforcing rules, it affects your home, your finances, and your peace of mind. That’s why we bring meticulous attention to detail and family-oriented care to every HOA matter we handle throughout Tampa, Clearwater, Palm Harbor, St. Petersburg, Jacksonville, and all of Florida.

We have a proven track record of skilled advocacy and offer comprehensive representation that spans the full spectrum of real estate legal concerns. Our commitment to client support means we provide personalized attention and ensure timely communication, so you always feel informed and supported throughout your legal journey. Whether you need to challenge improper fines, address selective enforcement, resolve assessment disputes, or respond to a threatened foreclosure, our team is here to help protect your rights.

Understanding the Role of Homeowners Associations in Florida

Homeowners associations (HOAs) play a significant role in Florida communities, often tasked with maintaining the aesthetic and structural integrity of neighborhoods. Florida law grants HOAs significant authority to enforce governing documents and manage common areas — but that authority is not unlimited. HOAs in Florida are regulated primarily under Chapter 720, Florida Statutes (the Florida Homeowners’ Association Act), supplemented by each community’s declaration of covenants, bylaws, and rules.

Disputes can arise over:

  • Assessments and special assessments
  • Property maintenance requirements
  • Architectural standards and modification requests
  • Meeting access and voting irregularities
  • Records requests and document access
  • Rental and leasing restrictions
  • Discrimination and fair-housing concerns
  • Selective or improper rule enforcement

These issues can create tension and may require professional legal guidance to navigate successfully.

Florida HOA Law: Chapter 720, Florida Statutes

Chapter 720 governs most Florida homeowners associations that were created by recorded covenants requiring membership in an association. Key subjects include:

  • Governing documents — declaration, articles, bylaws, and rules — and the statutory hierarchy between them
  • Board elections, recall, and director eligibility
  • Member voting rights and meeting notice requirements
  • Official records access (seven-business-day response rule) and permitted redactions
  • Regular and special assessments — authority to levy, notice, and collection
  • Fines and suspensions — statutory caps, notice, and hearing before a committee of non-board members
  • Covenant enforcement — including pre-suit mediation requirements under § 720.311
  • Claim of lien and HOA foreclosure procedures and defenses
  • Architectural review and ACC decisions

Where the statute and the declaration conflict, the statute generally controls (except where the statute specifically defers to governing documents). Careful review of the statute, declaration, and relevant documents is usually the first step in any HOA dispute.

Common HOA Disputes We Help Resolve

Our attorneys assist homeowners in a wide range of HOA-related disputes, including:

  • Improper fines and penalties (including fines imposed without the statutorily required hearing)
  • Selective enforcement of rules and restrictions
  • Assessment disputes and special assessment issues
  • Architectural denials and modification disputes
  • HOA liens and threatened foreclosure
  • Records access and document requests
  • Meeting notice and participation issues
  • Maintenance disputes involving common areas
  • Leasing and short-term rental restrictions
  • Discrimination concerns and related disputes
  • Developer-to-owner turnover disputes
  • Governing document amendments and challenges

HOA Fines, Suspensions & the Hearing Requirement

Chapter 720 places meaningful limits on an HOA’s ability to fine or suspend a homeowner:

  • Notice of the alleged violation and an opportunity to cure
  • A hearing before a committee of at least three members who are not board members or related to a board member
  • A fine cap per violation (subject to statutory exceptions for recurring violations)
  • No lien for fines unless the aggregate exceeds the statutory threshold

Fines imposed without following the correct procedure are vulnerable to challenge.

HOA Foreclosure Defense in Florida

If your HOA has recorded a claim of lien and is threatening foreclosure, the specific procedural history matters. Common defense angles include:

  • Standing and chain of assignment if the account was transferred
  • Proper pre-lien notice and pre-foreclosure notice
  • Accuracy of the amount claimed — late fees, attorney’s fees, and interest often invite scrutiny
  • Compliance with pre-suit mediation requirements under § 720.311
  • Underlying fine or special-assessment challenges
  • Service of process defects
  • Bankruptcy stay interactions

Do not ignore HOA collection letters, lien notices, or complaints — responsive deadlines are short and consequences for inaction are serious.

Selective Enforcement: A Common HOA Claim

Florida courts recognize that an HOA may be equitably barred from enforcing a rule that it has selectively enforced against similarly situated owners. A selective-enforcement defense often involves:

  • Documenting comparable violations that have gone unaddressed
  • Requesting official records showing enforcement actions
  • Evaluating recent waiver, abandonment, or acquiescence
  • Assessing whether the rule was properly adopted in the first place

Frequently Asked Questions About Florida HOA Disputes

What rights do I have to dispute an HOA decision in Florida?

Under Chapter 720, Florida Statutes, Florida homeowners have the right to challenge HOA decisions they believe are unfair, inconsistent with the governing documents, or contrary to statute. This can include disputing fines, assessments, or decisions regarding property use. Many disputes are subject to statutory pre-suit mediation under § 720.311 before a lawsuit may be filed.

What is the process for challenging an HOA decision?

Typically, you (1) review the governing documents and applicable statute, (2) document the decision and the evidence, (3) make a written request or appeal through the process set out in the documents, and (4) pursue pre-suit mediation where required. If those steps do not resolve the issue, litigation may be necessary.

Can my HOA fine me without a hearing?

Under Chapter 720, an HOA generally must give notice and an opportunity to be heard before a committee of three non-board members before imposing a fine or a suspension of use rights. A fine imposed without that procedure is subject to challenge.

How much can a Florida HOA fine a homeowner?

Fines are subject to a statutory per-violation cap and aggregate limits, with exceptions for continuing violations. The exact figures are updated by the Legislature periodically. Review the current statute for specific amounts, and review your declaration for any lower cap.

Can my HOA foreclose on my home?

Yes — in some circumstances, an HOA may pursue foreclosure on a recorded claim of lien after following required statutory notice procedures. Defenses include standing, pre-suit mediation compliance, accuracy of the amount claimed, and validity of the underlying fines or assessments. See our related page on real estate litigation.

Do I have to go to court to dispute an HOA decision?

Not all disputes require court involvement. Many issues can be resolved through direct negotiation or alternative dispute resolution such as Chapter 720 pre-suit mediation. However, if those methods fail, litigation may be the next step to protect your rights. See also our related practice areas for COA disputes and Florida condominium law.

How do I request official records from my HOA?

Under Chapter 720, an HOA generally must make official records available for inspection within 10 business days of a written request (Chapter 718 provides a similar framework for condominiums with different timelines). The statute identifies specific categories of records that may be withheld or redacted, including attorney-client privileged materials and certain personnel and medical information.

Can the HOA restrict my ability to rent my home?

Possibly, subject to the declaration, bylaws, and statutory limitations. Florida law includes specific requirements regarding when and how rental restrictions apply to existing owners versus purchasers who acquire a property after the restriction is adopted. Whether a restriction applies to your property is often a fact-specific inquiry.

Is pre-suit mediation required?

Under § 720.311, Florida Statutes, certain categories of HOA disputes require the parties to offer pre-suit mediation before filing a lawsuit. The categories include covenant enforcement, parking, nuisance, amenities, and others. Meeting this requirement is critical — skipping it can lead to dismissal.

My HOA is only enforcing the rule against me. What can I do?

Selective enforcement can be a defense or claim when the association has allowed comparable violations to go unaddressed. Document comparable violations with photos and dates, request relevant official records, and consult counsel on how to present the defense.

For context on why HOA disputes escalate, read our article on common reasons homeowners may face litigation with an HOA.

Let Us Help You Protect Your Rights

We understand how frustrating HOA disputes can be. Our experienced legal team is ready to help protect you. Call us at (727) 275-9575 or fill out our online contact form. While our main office is in Palm Harbor, we also welcome clients at our offices in Destin, Tampa, and Clearwater, with consultations available by appointment.

Serving Tampa Bay, Clearwater, Palm Harbor, St. Petersburg, Jacksonville, and all of Florida.

Discuss Your Case Call (727) 275-9575